Two young cruise YouTubers recently faced a filming dilemma on P&O Cruises’ Ventura. Josh and Alfie, the creators of the Young at Sea YouTube channel, were midway through a four-night cruise from Southampton to Rotterdam. They were suddenly told to halt their ship-tour filming after a fellow passenger complained to reception. The warning suggested that continued filming might lead to “further action,” which the duo feared could mean a ban from Carnival UK.
The pair usually film during the early hours to avoid capturing other guests. This complaint left them anxious about recording anything at all. However, after a follow-up conversation with customer services, they were reassured. They could continue filming as long as they avoided zooming in on passengers, a guideline they already adhered to.
Passenger Reaction: Support, Suspicion, and Privacy Concerns
The duo shared their experience on Facebook, receiving a wave of support. Many commenters speculated that the complaint might have come from someone who didn’t want to be recognised. Some even joked that the person might have been “on the ship with someone they shouldn’t be.” Others questioned why P&O Cruises would limit filming when they usually encourage social media coverage.
Several people advised Josh and Alfie to speak directly with senior management or guest services. They argued that a single complaint shouldn’t dictate policy. Some noted that other vloggers had faced similar issues on different cruise lines, with companies often apologising once misunderstandings were resolved.
Not all feedback was positive. Some passengers felt that being filmed on holiday was intrusive. One person commented, “Accept that not everyone wants to be filmed by complete strangers and show a bit of respect to your fellow passengers.” Another suggested the duo should “forget the filming and enjoy the cruise.”
Privacy was a recurring theme. One commenter advised, “Film, but don’t show other passengers. I wouldn’t want you filming me… it’s an invasion of my privacy.” Others questioned the feasibility of enforcing a filming ban, noting that almost everyone takes photos and videos on board.
My Take
As a cruise YouTuber myself, I’ve never been asked to stop filming on a ship. However, I know of a few creators who have faced similar challenges. For me, the balance between privacy and content creation is straightforward. People’s right not to be filmed should come first. This is why responsible vloggers film at dawn when the decks and venues are empty.
By avoiding filming anyone or editing them out if they appear briefly, it’s possible to create respectful and useful content. Cruise holidays are about enjoyment and relaxation, and respecting fellow passengers’ privacy is key to a harmonious experience.
