In a recent turn of events, a French administrative court has halted the restrictions proposed by Nice’s mayor, Christian Estrosi, on large cruise ships. Estrosi had attempted to prevent the Voyager of the Seas from docking at Villefranche-sur-Mer. However, the court ruled that he had overstepped his authority.
Legal Ruling Favors National Authority
On 13th July 2025, the court sided with Prefect Laurent Hottiaux. It suspended Estrosi’s order from 9th July, which aimed to ban large cruise ships from Nice and limit visits to Villefranche-sur-Mer. The court clarified that only the prefect of the Alpes-Maritimes has the power to regulate ship movements.
Proposed Restrictions and Their Impact
Estrosi’s order sought to bar ships with over 450 passengers from docking at Nice. It also aimed to cap Villefranche-sur-Mer to 65 large ship visits annually, with no more than one per day. This would have affected five cruise calls to Nice in 2025 and 15 in 2026, out of 176 scheduled visits. Villefranche-sur-Mer would have seen disruptions to 12 calls this year and 53 in 2026, impacting over 200,000 passengers.
Environmental Concerns vs. Legal Boundaries
The mayor argued that these limits were crucial for environmental protection and sustainable tourism. However, the court found his actions illegal and potentially infringing on public freedoms. Estrosi responded by urging the French government to take responsibility if local authorities cannot regulate cruise visits independently.
The Voyager of the Seas Incident
The legal case followed a dramatic incident on 3rd July 2025. Estrosi approached the Voyager of the Seas by boat, attempting to deliver his order to the captain. The captain, adhering to maritime law, refused to accept the mayor aboard due to lack of proper authority. This confrontation was widely shared online, drawing criticism from cruise industry advocates.
Cruise Industry’s Response
Philomène Bouchon, Director of Strategic Communications at the Cruise Lines International Association (CLIA), highlighted that access to ships is restricted to authorised individuals. CLIA also clarified that no cruise ban was in place, and Voyager of the Seas had been properly authorised. Bouchon described the mayor’s actions as “deeply regrettable.”
For UK cruise holidaygoers, this ruling ensures that planned itineraries to Nice and Villefranche-sur-Mer remain unaffected. The decision underscores the importance of national jurisdiction in regulating cruise ship movements, balancing local concerns with broader legal frameworks.
Leave a Reply