Carnival Cruise Line is currently embroiled in a legal battle following a personal injury claim from a former passenger. The lawsuit, filed by Jorge Luis Alverio Nunez, alleges that he sustained severe burns while walking barefoot on the Lido Deck of the Carnival Magic during a cruise in May 2025. Nunez, a resident of Florida, initiated the legal proceedings in the Southern District of Florida on 11th May 2026, almost a year after the incident. He is seeking damages exceeding $5 million.
Incident Details
The incident reportedly occurred on 21st May 2025. Nunez claims he was walking from the pool area to a nearby lounge chair where he had left his shoes. This short walk, approximately twenty steps, allegedly resulted in second-degree burns to his feet due to the deck’s dangerously high temperature. Nunez asserts that these injuries led to severe pain, hospitalisation, physical disfigurement, and ongoing mobility issues.
Allegations of Negligence
The lawsuit accuses Carnival of negligence, arguing that the cruise line failed to maintain safe conditions and did not adequately warn passengers of potential risks. It remains unclear whether the incident was reported during the cruise or if medical treatment was sought onboard. Cruise ships typically have medical facilities to handle such emergencies. The filing also suggests that crew members did not take necessary actions to prevent the deck from becoming dangerously hot.
Deck Surface Temperature
A key issue in the case is whether the Lido Deck’s surface reached temperatures capable of causing significant burns. At the time, Carnival Magic was cruising to the Bahamas and Caribbean, where May temperatures typically range from 29–32°C (mid to upper 80s°F). Surfaces exposed to direct sunlight can become much hotter than the air temperature, sometimes exceeding 40°C (105°F). However, cruise ship decks are subject to sea breezes and damp conditions from pool activities, which can help lower surface temperatures. Carnival uses marine-grade materials and non-slip coatings designed to withstand harsh conditions, though they can still become uncomfortable under intense sunlight.
Lack of Warnings
The lawsuit also claims that passengers were not adequately warned about the risks of hot deck surfaces. According to the filing, there were no warning signs or verbal announcements advising guests of the potential hazard of walking barefoot. Carnival has periodic safety briefings, but it appears this specific risk was not addressed.
Leave a Reply